Real Help for Parents of Teens in Recovery
Are Parents the Cause of Addiction?

What is the best treatment for my child?
We do not recommend adolescent centers.
One of the biggest problems I see with parents is that they
fail to understand that addiction is a very serious disease, not a
parenting issue, and needs to be addressed as such.
When seeking help, Mom and Dad often find professionals who
want to treat them,
and act as if getting good communication between family members is the
solution. It's not. That is akin to using marriage counseling to treat
the family alcoholic.
If a young person is to
recover from any addiction, they need the same treatment as you or I.
Unfortunately, that isn't usually found in an adolescent-only center.
I do not recommend you send them there. Even a study recently
put out by the Rand Corporation found that centers that claim
more effectiveness with adolescents could not be verified. Download the Summery in PDF
Adolescent
centers make serious mistakes that can be avoided by you.
There are understandable reasons for these mistakes that are discussed
in scientific journals, but the upshot is: treat adolescents in
multigenerational centers and their chances for recovery go up
significantly (4-5 times!) It is best to place your son or daughter in
a multigenerational drug treatment center and/or after care that uses blended adult
and young people groups, or you are wasting your time and money. It has
been proven that disturbed and misguided young people that are placed
in groups with other misguided young people GET WORSE, seldom better.
SAMSA has shown that although most people who go through drug treatment
use drugs on on average of 29% less, post treatment, young people that
go to adolescent centers use drugs 13% MORE! Need to be convinced? Read
this paper: Changing
Assumptions in Treating Adolescents for Addiction: A
theoretical paper by Shelly Marshall.
Dear Shelly, How often do teenagers that have gone through treatment go
back to drugs? {You wrote that they increase their use, not decrease
following treatment!!! (sentence paraphrased)} Shelly, this has been
our experience as well with my agency, Treatment Resources for Youth
works with very violent, court-adjudicated DJJ youth. Our
funding agency still believes in group work (for $$ reasons) and my Cl.
Director is a very suburban, Ivory Tower type but he is definitely
coming to the same conclusions. Could you lead me in the
direction of the SAMSHA research you mention. SAMSHA is
always very revered by our founders.
I attended the Integral Institute in Clearwater last Jan. and heard you
speak on this topic and was in total agreement.
You don't have to use this ? in your Q and A Internet Section unless
you want. I am merely seeking a reference to back up my
beliefs when I write this year's grant. Thanks for all your help. K. M.
Treatment Resources for Youth
Baltimore, MD 21218
The book Young,
Sober, & Free is a recovery manual for your
adolescent, but includes a chapter to parents that can make a huge
difference in how you look at their problem with drugs. This book also
contains experiences and examples written by parents like you. To read
an excerpt, go to Amazon.com.
Although you can order from our Direct
Sales store at Day By Day, you will find lower prices on
Amazon.
Is it true that kids can't identify in AA because of the age barrier?
Just as alcoholism does not discriminate with age, neither does recovery.
It has recently been reported that youths do better in recovery groups that include peers, according to research presented at the recent Research Society on Alcoholism meeting in San Francisco.
In a study involving 74 male and female adolescents in 12-step programs, researchers John F. Kelly, Ph.D., of the VA Palo Alto Healthcare System and Mark Myers, Ph.D., and Sandra A. Brown, Ph.D., from the University of California at San Diego found that youths attending meetings with one or more people in their age group went to more meetings and were more likely to view the program as important to their recovery.<
"Adult composition and content of groups may be a barrier to more frequent youth attendance," the researchers concluded "Thus, sharing of experiences by older members may not be perceived by youth as helpful or relevant in dealing with their own life-stage recovery issues."
The problem with this type of finding is that people misinterpret what this means. People erroneously conclude that teens need all-peer or same age cohorts in order to recover. When you put teens into adolescent only treatment or recovery groups, they tend to get worse, not better. The BEST treatment and recovery options for young people is MULTIGENERATIONAL. Groups and treatment centers that draw on the strengths, experience, and role modeling of adults, the nurturing and wisdom of elders, and the identification and energy of other young people give everyone the best opportunity for balanced recovery.
If a young person doesn't want recovery, the first thing they mention is the generation gap. If they do want recovery, they make friends fast of all ages in the 12 Step rooms. In addition, today, especially in large cities, there are many hundreds of young people in 12 Step recovery.